USA PUBLIC TRANSIT, CAR CENTRIC INFRASTRUCTURE, & RACISM
I did some reading and took notes on the above subject, and decided to collate them all on here for easy access in case anyone else is interested. Bullet points under each link are points I found particularly important in regards to public transit.
Table of Contents
Why Public Transit?
Car Centric Infrastructure + Racism
Further Reading
Why Public Transit?
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES
45% of Americans don’t have access to public transportation
- For every $1 invested in public transportation there are $5 in economic returns
- Every billion dollars invested in public transportation creates 50,000 jobs
- Every 10 million dollars in capital investment creates $30,000 in increased business sales
- Every 10 million dollars in maintenance investment for public transportation creates $32,000 in increased business sales
- Home values are higher near public transportation (24% higher) and hotels become 11% more profitable
- Saves average household $10,000 a year on car management (which can go back into economy in other expenditures)
- 87% of all trips on public transportation have direct impact on local economy
SAFETY
- 10x safer per mile
- Accidents are 90% less likely to happen on public transportation
ENVIRONMENT
- Current public transportation saves USA 6 billion gallons of gas per year
- Currently reduces USA carbon footprint by 63 million metric tons per year
IMPROVES COMMUNITY HEALTH
- since one must walk from transit stop to home, can increase public activity
- reduces pollution and accident rates
ECONOMIC BENEFITS
- again, economic return of $4 from every $1 invested
- easier for people to stop for local businesses and such, increases overall community business
FUEL EFFICIENCY
- some public transit is electric or by renewable energy
- even when it’s gas, more efficient (less gas per person)
REDUCES AIR POLLUTION
- 85% of greenhouse gas emissions come from cars
- every person can save 20 pounds of carbon dioxide emissions a day by using public transportation.
EQUITABLE TRANSIT
- means that folks who can’t afford a car/gas or don’t have a license have more opportunity to get jobs and be a part of the workforce
IMPROVES PRODUCTIVITY
- since you can work while you travel or partake in hobbies, or even just rest (can’t do any of that when driving) it increases productivity overall
EQUITY
- some groups rely on public transportation more than others
- these groups include women, young adults, Black workers, and low-income workers
- lack of public transportation disproportionately affects disabled folks and senior citizens
- lack of public transportation contributes to racial/economic disparity by making things harder for folks who can't afford cars and reduces overall mobility
HEALTH EQUITY
- reduces accidents and injuries
- vehicular accidents are a leading cause of death for a lot of age groups
- reduced air pollution
- pollution from car emissions can increase the risk of cancer
- also contributes to damage to many systems of the body (immune, reproductive, digestive, neurological, cardiovascular and respiratory)
- ^ all of the above disproportionately affects people of color and low-income communities
- ^^ since they are more likely to be exposed to high amounts of traffic and other high-polluting areas
- makes it easier for people to access healthcare
- lack of transit disproportionately affects health outcomes of those who are disabled, elderly, or cannot drive
- ^ lack of overall mobility results in lesser health outcomes (depression, dementia, life expectancy)
- ^^ this is aided by public transportation, increasing options for social, business, and community engagement
- increases physical activity overall → better health outcomes
- increases health outcomes
- lower crash rates and crash severity
- public transportation has less than half the total death per mile rate for passengers than cars
- 1/10 fatality rate per mile for public transportation
- people walk or bike to public transportation which increases physical activity
- more cost effective
Car Centric Infrastructure + Racism
Infrastructure in the USA has been used as a tool to perpetuate segregation and racial/economic disparities. A prime example of this is in our transit infrastructure, both roads and public transportation
By increasing public transportation and funding it better, we can provide better opportunities for low income and Black communities, helping to repair the disparities in our country.
I can recall something about bridges being deliberately designed to not fit buses, making it harder for low-income families and POC to access places, but I haven’t found a source that confirms that so take it with a grain of salt.
HIGHWAY ACT OF 1956
- Pushed for construction of highways (benefiting suburban white communities) and destruction of Black community
- Road construction to destroy predominantly Black towns and regions, replace them with highways and interstates. Below are some examples
Example 1
- construction of Interstate 94 in St. Paul, Minnesota evacuated 1/7 of the entire black population in the city
Example 2
- construction of Interstate 579 completely destroyed a Black suburb in Pittsburg, Pennsylvania
- ^ separated the predominantly Black community from the rest of Pittsburg, essentially choking the town
- ^^ had a population of 44,000 in 1950, now only about 9,500
- ^^^ 400+ businesses were lost
Example 3
- construction of Interstate 95 in Florida completely destroyed Overtown, the cultural & economic center of the Black community in Miami
- ^ one of the highway interchanges involved took 40 square blocks and removed homes of 10,000 people
- ^^ once “the Harlem of Miami”, no sign even remains
*this also talks about other forms of segregation in infrastructure, i’m taking notes on the road/transit based parts
- ”Racism physically built into some of our highways,” Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigeg
- initial 20 years of the Highway Act of 1956 displaced 475,000 families and over a million people
- ^ weakened urban communities and aided segregation
- communities in Pennsylvania that are predominantly POC or single parent families have less bridges
- bridges in those areas also tend to be “restrictive”, limiting imports and transportation services
Further Reading
t4america.org/2021/10/20/say-hello-to-induced-demand/
transfersmagazine.org/magazine-article/issue-9/spreading-the-gospel-of-induced-demand/
engineering.cmu.edu/news-events/news/2020/09/11-racial-inequity-infrastructure.html
texasimpact.org/2022/06/the-unsustainable-reality-of-a-car-centric-united-states
csengineermag.com/we-need-to-talk-about-systemic-racism-in-infrastructure
kinder.rice.edu/urbanedge/racism-has-shaped-public-transit-and-its-riddled-inequities
thephiladelphiacitizen.org/systemic-racism-infrastructure/